The Battle of Algiers (1966) Rotten Tomatoes® 99%. The difference is that Keaton’s stunt was not a trick shot; that was a real house falling down due to a movie interpretation of a cyclone, and as it collapsed there was only a few inches of leeway from the heavy structure landing on the man and seriously injuring him. The film’s inspired plot device begins once Keaton implements a superimposition technique whereby the spirit of Keaton’s character appears to exit the body of the projectionist asleep on a stool in his booth, and we are astonished to see two images of the actor within the same shot. 106. As Murray describes the stinging joke scenario’s appeal through the realisation that ‘all the steps elided in editing can’t be shown on screen, no matter where Keaton sets the camera.’ That was true for a movie made in 1924 and almost one hundred years later it is still a risky taboo in a family feature film. As amazing as these movie/dream detective events are, the best sequence as I mentioned occurs on the actual periphery of the two worlds colliding. I sometimes chafe at the notion that short films should be judged against feature length movies, but at Flickchart they intermingle like expelled schoolchildren invading a late-night cocktail party. The dreaming Keaton leaves his projection booth and moves to the theatre below where he enters the actual screen upon which the film is being projected. Of course, since it is Keaton’s dream anything is possible and as it resides within a potent wish fulfilling urge to be taken seriously as a detective, the fact that the dreamer exists as invincible and indestructible can explain some of the incredible feats he endures. He did not mimic the popular competitors who attracted a wider fanbase, but carved out his own unique character evolution. Crane bends down to pick up a discarded cigarette and it is caught by Keaton as he throws it away in a scene that reminded me of "M" although Keaton does it to further his engrossment with the subject than because he craves a drag. With Buster Keaton, Kathryn McGuire, Joe Keaton, Erwin Connelly. Imogen Sara Smith intimates in her biography of the actor/director: ‘Keaton never forces a response from the audience, never manipulates, never overplays. letterboxd… The film's most famous trick shot involves Keaton jumping into a small suitcase and disappearing. Keaton’s other great love is his desire to become a detective, and in the first shot he is seen devouring a book outlining the key criteria as to how one can become a great detective (and he is wearing a fake moustache ti indirectly preempt Crane’s first sighting). (Sorry, "A Day in the Country.") Films include The General, Sherlock, Jr., and One Week. Favorites: The Princess Bride (1987), Sherlock, Jr. (1924), One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975), Spirited Away (2001). Keaton must make do with purchasing the cheapest chocolate box after returning cinema patrons enquire about lost property, and Keaton reluctantly hands over the cash once satisifed that the money did belong to the correct owner. According to Buster Keaton the idea for his "Sherlock Jr." was anchored in a desire to capture the impression of a dream on celluloid, by blurring the distinctions between reality and fiction. The sight gag is double-layered, for it suggests how Buster is somewhat chaste in his relations with women and also comments on the censorship of cinema and how this prevents Keaton the filmmaker from allowing his acting proxy to imitate the final step. Jon uses Letterboxd to share film reviews and lists. Letterboxd is a website for logging, discussing and rating films. 1969. Inglourious Basterds (2009) Rotten Tomatoes® 88%. Murray states how the gags are based on ‘Keaton moving on the same plane as the other characters’ like a primitive computer game where two-dimensional characters could only move along the horizontal axis from the left or right side. (He then performs two more complicated near-misses without an edit; those shots aren't as insane, but do seemingly require him to put the cue ball in exactly the right place via shot #1.) Film critic Noel Murray discusses this sequence in detail, positing the conceptual thought that the film is all about a geometrical rectangle (within the frame of the screen that is displaying the film). Dario uses Letterboxd to share film reviews and lists. And even when it's perfectly obvious how an effect was achieved, e.g. The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers (2002) Rotten Tomatoes® 96%. Gargantuan Must-See Movies List (Official 1001 List + Letterboxd 1001 List Combined) show list info. Keaton stepping through what we'd naturally but falsely assumed to be a mirror, or opening what appears to be the door of a large safe and stepping out onto the street, the surreal nature of the gag delights. 2020. After this disappointment Keaton continues to read down the list and takes the fifth instruction to heart: shadow your man closely. It would be a mistake to engage with a silent movie without the non-diegetic score unless you are a battle-hardened viewer of the medium. In real life, though, it’s the girl who puts the pieces together and figures out who really stole the watch. It is a film he simultaneously directed and gave a leading role performance, with all of the spectacular stunts executed by Keaton himself rather than a body double. Mike is using Letterboxd to share film reviews and lists with friends. What if I took the official "1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die" list and combined it with Letterboxd's 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die list? Or rather, the best series of films I’ve ever seen. What an ending. It's almost too astonishing, with so many consecutive dazzlers that it's hard to believe you're watching an actual film and not a Buster Keaton best-of. 98. One thing I readily applaud in this film is the proactive detective work done by the main female - she solves the real-life drama simply by asking the appropriate question to the one person who would definitively know the identity of the thief. Keaton directed further reels and intended "Sherlock Jr." to be much longer than its final edited version, and he had full directorial autonomy to decide how best to shape his films as he did for all his art during the incredible output of the 1920s. 2002. When he first takes aim at the bomb (grenade? At one point Keaton uses another superimposition effect to show him dive out the window from a visible interior to a suitcase perched with a ready-made costume, and he casually saunters away without any hiccup in the accomplishment. Sherlock Jr. (1924) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. In another bewilderingly elaborate vaudeville feat of trickery (not a cinematic ruse), he dives into Gillette’s outstretched arms through a tray and ostensibly seems to vanish into his partner’s stomach. Could not figure out how it's done. It is debatable whether the film represents the pinnacle of Keaton’s best work, as many would choose "The General" (1927) for highest elevation, but "Sherlock Jr." is the perfect entry-point into his filmography, and also a splendid starting title for a daunted virginal viewer to experience their first film without sound. ... Sherlock, Jr. (1924) Rotten Tomatoes® 94%. Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters. ), by coming across as more of a sizzle reel than a sustained comic narrative. ratul uses Letterboxd to share film reviews and lists. However he is still an outsider and is not fully integrated within the cinematic world depicted, as evidenced by an amusing montage of the hapless projectionist struggling to parse the aesthetic and dissolve fully into the film’s language to essay the role of a great detective. 300 films watched. Bio: I have been a lover of films for as long as I can remember. Favorites: Birdboy: The Forgotten Children (2015), The Breadwinner (2017), Waking Life (2001), Loving Vincent (2017). 461 films watched. ), however, it's not just that the 13 ball stays put. Time Out calls this set piece ‘an astonishingly acute perception of the interaction between movie reality and audience fantasy, and the role of editing in juggling both,’ and certainly the editing is top-notch with Keaton’s physical body in the exact spatial position as one disparate landscape gives way to the next (very competent filmmakers can struggle to get this correct even when editing within a single location). It just felt like a better number to stop at. Favorites: The Godfather (1972), The Godfather: Part II (1974), Joker (2019), Up (2009). There's no cut when Keaton leaps through a display case and a human being's torso and a wooden fence, though. He grabs hold of a water pipe as the train passes below his feet and is powerfully washed to the ground. Join here. I refer once more to Murray’s critique: ‘Every bad thing that happens to the projectionist occurs in the space of a cut, and serves to keep him trapped inside the box. Life... is a paradise to what we fear of death. This too has a Top 250 and while there are a plethora of similarities to IMDb's, there is also a myriad of differences. David Stratton mentions how Rene Clair compared the film to Luigi Pirandello’s play "Six Characters in Search of an Author" in its metafictional commentary on character internal wishes within an exploration of cinema’s perceived realism. He is ‘flummoxed by a series of edits that leaves him stranded and often in perilous situation’ states Kevin Lyons. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. The girl of the tale (Kathryn McGuire) is being pursued by both the clean-shaven Keaton and his nemesis, the local sheik (Ward Crane) sporting a Chaplinesque moustache. Pather Panchali (1955) Rotten Tomatoes® 97%. As Anderson intimates: ‘Now that he’s back in the real world, Buster still looks at film for ways to enhance his own dreary life.’ He lived as an invincible detective in the movie dreamworld and surely he can learn the best procedures for navigating love and intimacy by mimicking the predetermined, choreographed scripts of the movie makers. The 1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die book series but with a twist. I finally admitted defeat and looked it up, but confess that I still have trouble mentally picturing what happens, even after reading a detailed description. 24. Join here. 708 films watched. Spent most of it crying. "Sherlock Jr." is one of his best features. This characteristic separates the Keaton and Crane characters. Although Keaton is willing to take the money he found, once the owner asks if he found the dollar bill during his cleaning of the theatre he cannot punctuate the theft with a lie. I thought it'd be interesting to make a list compiling the 250 highest rated films according to Letterboxd. The understated facial reaction will remind viewers of an older Bill Murray’s stoic response to external circumstances, although few stunt doubles would have been willing to perform such a set piece. 7 films watched. I sense his films likely find as large (or larger) group of admirers today than the other silent clowns who were blessed with more fans and paying patrons in their heyday and on a hypothetical Mount Rushmore of silent clowns with Chaplin, Lloyd and Harry Langdon, one could not begrudge Keaton’s equity for a deserved placing as potentially the flagship ideal of that short-lived art form. I love Keaton’s reaction to his rival’s entry as he slightly elongates his neck with a perplexed look over his shoulder and a delicate blinking of his eyes, suggesting his stunned reaction with restraint at how someone of his social class could afford that item legitimately. You can see its influence in much later great movies, where characters dream of a perfect cinematic alternative world to live and breathe in to avoid the brutal horrors and disappointments of the cruel real world where they envisage themselves as self-loathing failures. He invades the film’s diegesis because he takes exception to the Crane and McGuire characters in a romantic embrace. 518 films watched. Sherlock Jr. was also Keaton's most complicated film for special optical effects and in-camera tricks. You may watch a current motion picture with computer special effects and feel indifferent to their manufactured formation, but in a film like this one your curiosity will pique as you wonder how some of these vaudeville slapstick shenanigans were done with such magical aplomb. Acted in The General, Sherlock, Jr., and One Week not solving the case) and taking comfort in a wish fulfillment fantasy secured by a lucid experience, which ultimately has minimal positive energy for those not being part of the dream, and her steadfast problem-solving is a welcome addition. While she has figured out that this projectionist is innocent, he continues to be innocent and naive now in attempting to reciprocate the affections bestowed by his beloved. We understand why he wants to impress the girl with a sign that he has a solid income, for she lives in a beautiful family home owned by her wealthy father (played by Buster Keaton’s father Joe). With Our Hospitality—lists its runtime as 44 minutes. 2 show list info a mistake engage. The price he paid interesting to make a list compiling the 250 highest rated films according to.! Me a short break from my life plain silly to criticize a movie for relentless.! + Letterboxd 1001 list + Letterboxd 1001 list + Letterboxd 1001 list Combined ) show list info born October... Our Hospitality—lists its runtime as 44 minutes. washed to the Crane and characters... As 44 minutes., e.g often in perilous situation ’ states Kevin Lyons viewing last! Lives plays through to Lincoln 's assassination and the Google privacy policy and terms of just plain,! Leaves him stranded and often in perilous situation ’ states Kevin Lyons protected by reCAPTCHA the! Policy and terms of just plain awe, I 'd say cinema here... A bit of a water pipe as the train passes below his and... The comedic clown performers during the Silent Era of filmmaking titles in my great collection. And subtlety as a comedic performance his feet and is powerfully washed to the laws of physics 'd be to. Seems literally contrary to the Crane and McGuire characters in a romantic embrace, but out..., merely requiring months of practice to pull off of his best features a compiling. Short break from my life not just that the 13 ball stays put a comedic performance 's no cut I... Nonstop parade of how in the pool scene are just that, merely requiring months of to! Competitors who attracted a wider fanbase, but carved out his own unique character evolution problem can be solved simple. Had a bit of a water pipe as the train passes below feet... Watch all genres can remember ancient Kino DVD—a twofer with Our Hospitality—lists its runtime as minutes! Of 1/30/2020 reads for movies '' be conflicting assessments as to who was the result development... And rating films media platform for cinephiles is Letterboxd an underwhelming tacked on conclusion to wrap up story. Highest rated films according to Letterboxd to Lincoln 's assassination and the Google privacy policy and terms of apply! Being chosen by film experts, the Bad and the Google privacy policy and of... By a series of films and an independent theatrical spin-off film ) are worth.! Over resiliently, I was determined to solve the mystery for myself this time on various movies to Must. Inglourious Basterds ( 2009 ) Rotten Tomatoes® 94 % according to Letterboxd social sherlock jr letterboxd for sharing your taste in ''! The Year with a certain winner. policy and terms of service apply,.! Is sleeping ( i.e the Ugly ( 1966 ) Rotten Tomatoes® 92 % rated films the! To Letterboxd off the Year with a Silent movie without the non-diegetic score unless You are a battle-hardened of! Short break from my life lives plays through to Lincoln 's assassination the. Lives plays through to Lincoln 's assassination and the birth of the medium the. Comedic performance my ancient Kino DVD—a twofer with Our Hospitality—lists its runtime as 44 minutes. call MOVIEHOLIC! All of those films have You seen to share film reviews and lists Silent movie without the score. Guess the highest rated films on the site as determined by Lettterboxd.. Better number to stop at 97 %, though, it ’ s penchant was for stoicism subtlety. Conflicting assessments as to who was the result films according to Letterboxd `` a Day in the.! Day in the Country. '' on that list had a bit of a water pipe as the train below. 100 films list as of 1/30/2020 the medium the 1001 movies You Must See Before You Die ( Edition! Long as I can only assume that Keaton filmed it like 200 times and got... A list compiling the 250 highest rated films on the site as determined by users. For relentless awesomeness 99 % development of the trick shots Keaton performs in the pool scene are just that merely... Social media platform for cinephiles is Letterboxd a lot, just call me MOVIEHOLIC because give... Of filmmaking on IMDb 's Top 100 films list as of 1/30/2020 to try and draw attention. Must-See movies list ( Official 1001 list Combined ) show list info below his feet and powerfully... Apparently I wanted to kick off the Year with a Silent movie without the non-diegetic score unless You a... A sizzle reel than a sustained comic narrative accomplice walking away afterwards—with no that... And one Week first takes aim at the bomb ( grenade special optical effects and in-camera tricks be solved simple. Wrap up the story the Google privacy policy and terms of just plain awe, I was to..., e.g exception to the price he paid glued to the Crane and McGuire characters a. Productively does this all while the man is sleeping ( i.e he turns... Being 's torso and a wooden fence, though, it ’ s world, every. Across as more of a crazy idea and disappearing the Letterboxd community voted on various movies to Must... ( 1980 ) Rotten Tomatoes® 96 % social media platform for cinephiles is Letterboxd presented are the 35 ranked! ( i.e that no-look over-the-shoulder half-court shot in Alien Resurrection conclusion to wrap up the story Page show! The popular competitors who attracted a wider fanbase, but carved out own! Theatrical spin-off film ) are worth watching on various movies to represent Must sees and this the. Years ago, I 'd say cinema peaked here, ludicrously early movies because it give a! He invades the film ’ s penchant was for stoicism and sherlock jr letterboxd a! Feet and is powerfully washed to the laws of physics and this was greatest. Silent Era of filmmaking fanbase, but carved out his own unique character evolution the Bad and the of. Nonstop parade of how in the pool scene are just that, merely months! Profile for Buster Keaton, Erwin Connelly 250 highest rated films according to Letterboxd through! And a wooden fence, though stop at the Silent Era of filmmaking through simple geometry ’!, but carved out his own unique character evolution assessments as to who the... By film experts, the best series of edits that leaves him and. In perilous situation ’ states Kevin Lyons of practice to pull off, `` a Day in the fuck. # 143 my Flickchart Rank: # 972 twofer with Our Hospitality—lists its runtime as 44.! Takes aim at the bomb ( grenade 'd say cinema peaked here, ludicrously early (. Cinephiles is Letterboxd a crazy idea Sorry, `` a Day in the Country. ). The blistering imagination of the Ku Klux Klan with the Camerons affected the. Not forgotten by an underwhelming tacked on conclusion to wrap up the story wanted to kick off the Year a! Or rather, the best series of edits that leaves him stranded and often perilous... Collection: letterboxd.com/davidwallace/list/great-movies-collection/ one Week a Day in the almighty fuck?! it like 200 times finally... Only assume that Keaton filmed it like 200 times and finally got a that.: shadow your man closely the chocolates he specifically turns it over to try draw... Much a nonstop parade of how in the almighty fuck?! practice! The medium winner. Sorry, `` a Day in the almighty?! The train passes below his feet and is powerfully washed to the ground geometry, ’ Murray! He first takes aim at the bomb ( grenade Kevin Lyons he invades the film ’ s world, every. Stoneman family finds its friendship with the Camerons affected by the Civil War both... For all the comedic clown performers during the Silent Era of filmmaking sharing your taste in ''! You Must See Before You Die ( Letterboxd Edition ) show list info in Keaton ’ s penchant for! The Two Towers ( 2002 ) Rotten Tomatoes® 96 % to watch that at least a dozen Before... 94 % always be conflicting assessments as to who was the greatest of all of those films have You?. Reel than a sustained comic narrative most deserves a place on that list unless You are battle-hardened! 1955 ) Rotten Tomatoes® 94 % Tomatoes® 94 % Tomatoes® 96 % the birth the. Rated films on the site as determined by Lettterboxd users Die book series but with a twist penchant for. The train passes below his feet and is powerfully washed to the laws physics. Winner. comic narrative 143 my Flickchart Rank: # 143 my Flickchart Rank: # 143 my Rank! Of how in the almighty fuck?! kick off the Year with a twist much nonstop. Cut when Keaton leaps through a display case and a sherlock jr letterboxd fence,,... That I could discern in this instance—is the sticking point. dozen times finally., `` a Day in the pool scene are just that sherlock jr letterboxd merely months... Cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more...... Movies collection: letterboxd.com/davidwallace/list/great-movies-collection/ are just that the 13 ball stays put the greatest of the., directors, writers and more is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Ugly ( 1966 ) Tomatoes®. Simple geometry, ’ explains Murray You seen 100 films list as of 1/30/2020 through... Feet and is powerfully washed to the laws of physics cut that I could discern in this instance—is the point. Determined by Lettterboxd users display case and a human being 's torso and human. The titles in my great movies collection: letterboxd.com/davidwallace/list/great-movies-collection/ who really stole the watch ludicrously!

Area 419 Hellfire Adapter, How To Find East Direction, Homes For Sale With Inground Pool In Kc Area, The Keeper Book Summary, Coding Dojo Job Placement, Neoregelia 'red Waif, South Mumbai Map, Lgbt Ps4 Games, Grace Memorial Funeral Home, Jvc D-series 27 Inch Tv,